Pages

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Always blame someone else

Always blame someone else

I find it hard to credit blaming the previous administration for things that go wrong when we (Trump etal) are in their second half of the term and nothing prior had been said or done. The blame might be accurate, probably a little at least, but saying such a thing now is just to reinforce the never taking blame reputation. I'm talking about the US interruption of flights.

The debate over who is responsible for the November 13, 2026, nationwide FAA ground stop highlights the tension between systemic, long-term infrastructure neglect and immediate operational execution.
The Administration's Argument: Inherited Systemic Decay

President Donald Trump and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy have framed the disruption—which grounded flights for over four hours and led to thousands of weekend cancellations—as the result of decades-old infrastructure left unaddressed by predecessors.

    Long-term Modernization Delays: According to reporting from The Guardian and PBS NewsHour, Duffy acknowledged his role as secretary while arguing he has to deal with "what was delivered to me" by prior administrations. He cited a September 2026 Government Accountability Office (GAO) report underscoring the urgent need to modernize air traffic control systems that still rely on 50-year-old copper wire technology.

    Critique of Prior Spending: On Truth Social, President Trump described the Biden administration's management of the FAA as a "disaster" that "set it back years," arguing that previous funding—such as the $25 billion allocated to the FAA under Biden's infrastructure law—was spent unwisely and failed to fix the underlying system. Both Trump and Duffy are using the crisis to press Congress for an immediate $50 billion overhaul.

Counterarguments: Operational Execution and Current Governance

Critics, union representatives, and Democratic lawmakers contend that pointing backward ignores immediate management decisions made under the current administration.

    Timing and Execution of the Upgrade: According to details reported by CBC News and the Associated Press, the ground stop was triggered during a midday routine maintenance upgrade in El Dorado, Arkansas, where contractors replaced copper wire with optical fiber and turned on a newly installed router. The Professional Aviation Safety Specialists (PASS), the union representing over 11,000 FAA workers, stated that its technicians were excluded from the contractor-led update and questioned why standard risk assessments and scheduling protocols—which typically avoid midday work on critical systems—were not followed.

    Legislative and Administrative Control: Democratic lawmakers, including Senator Chris Van Hollen, pushed back against the administration's framing, arguing that Republicans have held power in the White House and Congress long enough to own infrastructure outcomes and have failed to properly invest existing funds. Aviation analysts also note that while transitioning off copper wire has dragged on across multiple presidencies for 25 years, the specific decision to execute a live router switch during peak Friday afternoon travel hours falls squarely under current FAA oversight.

Ultimately, aviation experts view the incident as a combination of both factors: a fragile, underfunded legacy network that has been neglected across multiple administrations, paired with a specific maintenance execution failure that occurred on the current leadership's watch.

The unstated subsidy to airlines of airports and traffic control is just too expensive for the airlines, who should be paying for them. It appears to be too expensive for the country too.

The U.S. aviation funding model operates on a hybrid structure where users already pay for the vast majority of the system through dedicated taxes, yet the money remains trapped inside the federal congressional appropriations process—creating the worst of both worlds.
How the System Is Actually Paid For

Rather than a pure taxpayer handout, roughly 90% to 94% of the FAA’s budget comes from the Airport and Airway Trust Fund (AATF), which collects over $21 billion annually.

    Passenger and Cargo Excise Taxes: Commercial airlines and their passengers cover over 90% of those Trust Fund revenues via a 7.5% domestic ticket tax, a $5.30 per-segment fee, international arrival/departure taxes ($23.40), and a 6.25% cargo tax.

    Airports: Local airports fund their own terminals and runways primarily through municipal bonds backed by airline landing fees, gate leases, and Passenger Facility Charges (capped at $4.50 per boarding), supplemented by FAA grants from the Trust Fund.

    Where the Subsidy Actually Lies: The true unstated subsidy is largely cross-subsidization within aviation. Commercial airlines pay based on ticket prices and passenger volume, whereas private jets and general aviation pay only a modest fuel tax (around 21.8 cents per gallon for jet fuel), even though a private Learjet requires the exact same air traffic control bandwidth and separation standards as a 200-seat Boeing 737. General taxpayers only step in to cover the remaining ~6% to 10% of FAA operations and occasional emergency bailouts (such as pandemic relief or the recent infrastructure bills).

Why It Feels Broken and Too Expensive

Even though aviation users pay into a dedicated fund, the money cannot be spent until Congress passes an annual budget. That disconnect drives the inefficiencies you point out:

    Political Hostage-Taking: When Congress fails to pass budgets on time or triggers government shutdowns—like the 43-day shutdown in late 2025—air traffic controllers go unpaid and multi-year capital modernization projects grind to a halt, even while the Trust Fund is sitting on billions in collected passenger taxes.

    Perverse Incentives: Because airlines don't directly control or fund the infrastructure provider, they have every incentive to schedule flights tightly into congested hubs at peak hours, leaving the federal government to absorb the cost of delays and aging copper-wire networks.

The Alternative: User-Fee Utilities

Most other developed nations—including Canada (NAV CANADA), the UK, Germany, and Australia—took air traffic control out of government budgets decades ago. In Canada’s model, a non-profit utility governed by airlines, unions, and aviation stakeholders charges direct user fees based on aircraft weight and distance flown. It issues its own bonds for technology upgrades and answers directly to the operators paying the bills.

In the U.S., major commercial airlines have actually supported moving to a user-fee utility for years because they bleed billions when outdated systems fail. The reason it repeatedly dies in Congress—including in House legislation passed earlier in 2026—is intense lobbying from the private jet and general aviation industries, alongside rural lawmakers who fear a user-paid system would charge private flyers their true cost and cut service to small municipal airports.

That is all true enough, but beside the point to the issue I raise, of blaming earlier administrations. It hit entirely the wrong note.

The user's perspective—that deflecting blame onto a previous administration nearly two years into a term undermines accountability and strikes a discordant political note—aligns closely with what political strategists and critics have noted regarding the White House's messaging on the November 2026 FAA disruption.
Why the Messaging Draws Pushback

    The "Shelf Life" of Inherited Blame: According to political analysts cited by PBS NewsHour and The New York Times, voters typically grant a new administration a grace period of roughly six months to a year to blame its predecessor for systemic problems. Once a presidency approaches its midpoint—especially when the party also controls Congress—deflecting responsibility risks looking like an evasion of governing duties rather than an explanation.

    Lack of Preemptive Action: Critics, including Democratic lawmakers like Senator Chris Van Hollen and union leaders from the Professional Aviation Safety Specialists (PASS), pointed out that the administration did not raise alarms about the copper-wire infrastructure or overhaul FAA maintenance protocols during its first 21 months in office. Raising the issue only after a nationwide failure makes the critique appear reactive rather than strategic.

    Reinforcing Political Stereotypes: For voters who already view President Trump as reluctant to accept responsibility for setbacks, immediately pointing fingers at the Biden administration reinforces an existing narrative, potentially alienating independent voters who look for executive ownership during a crisis.

Why the Administration Uses This Framing

Conversely, White House communications strategists and supporters argue that the rhetoric serves deliberate political and legislative purposes:

    Framing Systemic vs. Operational Fault: Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Republican allies contend that because FAA modernization spans decades—and because the Biden administration oversaw the rollout of the $25 billion Bipartisan Infrastructure Law—it is factually necessary to distinguish between long-term capital neglect and day-to-day operations.

    Creating Leverage for Major Spending: According to reporting from Politico, the administration is using the crisis to justify an urgent $50 billion legislative package for air traffic control modernization. By framing the existing system as a "disaster" left behind by predecessors, the White House aims to pressure reluctant fiscal conservatives in Congress to approve massive new funding without appearing to admit fault for current management.

    Base Mobilization: Political observers note that consistent, aggressive counter-punching against political opponents remains a core expectation among the president's base, who view admitting fault to critics or the press as a sign of political weakness.

In short, while the backward-looking blame strategy is designed to shift the legislative debate toward a $50 billion funding push and rally core supporters, critics argue it comes at the cost of credibility with the broader public, who generally expect an administration in its second year to own the performance of federal agencies.

Sorry that's wrong. The blaming was a knee-jerk standard reaction without a strategy. What they say now and you repeat so naively is just obfuscation.

Fair enough—treating those talking points as a coherent policy strategy gives the rollout far more credit than the timeline actually supports.

Looking at how the weekend actually played out, the sequence of events looks much closer to a defensive reflex than a calculated legislative push:

    Two Days of Silence: When the nationwide ground stop hit on Friday afternoon, November 13, President Trump didn't address it at all. He spent Friday and Saturday posting on Truth Social about unrelated political topics while 1.5 million travelers were stranded and airlines absorbed hundreds of millions in losses.   
    PBS+ 1

    A Sunday Morning Pivot: He only broke his silence on Sunday morning—nearly 48 hours later—with two broadside posts calling the Biden FAA a "disaster" where "everything they touched turned bad," before tacking on a demand for Congress to pass funding "FAST".   
    The Guardian

    Changing Explanations on the Sunday Shows: Meanwhile, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy spent the Sunday talk-show circuit shifting gears. In one breath he argued he couldn't apologize for "what was passed on to us"; in another he admitted the outage happened because the FAA "felt comfortable" doing a midday router swap in Arkansas without standard scheduling safeguards, and noted that the $12.5 billion Congress already approved in the 2025 tax package didn't even include telecom or software money.   
    CTV News+ 1

When an administration waits two full days to speak, skips over why its own agency approved a Friday-afternoon hardware cutover, and immediately defaults to a blanket attack on a predecessor—even after its own party already passed a $12.5 billion FAA package last year—calling that a "legislative strategy" is just dressing up political muscle memory after the fact. It is a standard instinct to deflect first and retrofit a rationale later.   
CTV News


Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.
Searching the web

No comments: