Joy. I mean being so happy at something you just want to jump and shout, although of course you don't. It is I think the memory of a few such moments that keeps one alive.
My parents came to Boston to visit after college while I was living there and I arranged an expensive table at Pops. Three of us and by luck the forth seat a major celebrity, not any celebrity but one of my dad's very favorites. It was such a joy watching his delight and efforts to stay civilized and not gush.
There is a particular brand of joy that belongs exclusively to watching someone you love experience a stroke of pure, unscripted good fortune—especially when it happens in a setting you set in motion.
Symphony Hall during Boston Pops has its own built-in theater to begin with: the small round tables on the floor, the clink of glasses, the sense of an occasion being slightly more festive than a standard concert. Having the fourth chair at a table for four filled by a stranger is already a minor gamble of proximity. Having it filled by someone your father genuinely admired turns an ordinary evening into one of those rare alignments where you get to sit back and watch a grown man work very hard at keeping his composure.
That tension—between wanting to jump and shout and maintaining the quiet dignity expected of a polite dinner companion—is often half the charm of the memory. You get the double pleasure of his genuine delight and the affectionate amusement of seeing him carefully ration his enthusiasm so as not to intrude.
Who was the celebrity, and did your father manage to strike up a real conversation with them before the music started?
My family didn't drink alcohol, and when he ordered champagne for us and they politely declined, begging health (not true but better than being sanctimonious) he smiled and said he would pass then too as it was better and he had to perform later. I think I should pass on your question on the identity.
Fair enough on keeping the name private—the grace of the moment speaks entirely for itself without needing a marquee attached.
That exchange over the champagne captures a kind of social choreography that is increasingly rare: two different sets of manners meeting halfway so no one feels awkward. Your parents offered a white lie purely to protect a stranger from feeling judged, and he immediately matched their courtesy by inventing a practical excuse of his own so they wouldn't feel like spoilsports at their own table.
When you add that he was actually on the program to perform later that evening, your father's restraint becomes even more impressive. Sitting inches away from a favorite artist who is about to take the stage—and watching that artist be genuinely gracious in private—is the exact sort of quiet, unrepeatable perfection that earns a permanent place in memory.
Did your father talk about that evening for years afterward, or was it the kind of memory your family held onto quietly?
He was not on the program; he was Feidler's little surprise.
That adds a whole other layer to it. Arthur Fiedler loved pulling off those unannounced guest appearances at Symphony Hall—bringing someone out mid-concert just to watch the audience erupt.
So your father wasn't even bracing himself for a brush with fame; he sat down at a table expecting a pleasant night with his family and ended up sharing bread and small talk with a hero who was quietly waiting in plain sight for his cue. That kind of double surprise—first at the table, then seeing him walk out onto the stage under Fiedler's baton—makes the whole memory feel almost like a conspired gift.
Did the two of you ever figure out whether the seating was pure luck of the box office, or if Fiedler's people liked placing surprise guests at tables with ordinary families so they wouldn't draw attention before the reveal?
At intermission there was an autograph line, and I remarked he should charge a fee. He said he was paid enough and this was a pleasant part of the job.
That answer fits right in with the champagne gesture—no grandstanding, no false modesty, just a straightforward, unpretentious sense of proportion about his work and the people who came to hear him.
When someone you admire turns out to be decent and grounded when nobody is keeping score, it protects the memory from ever souring. You get to keep the pure joy of that evening intact, right down to the small details of how everyone at the table conducted themselves.
What a fine evening to have engineered for your parents, and to still carry around decades later.
Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.
Chats with an AI
I'm an 83 yr US expat living in rural Cambodia. These are chats with AIs. fmerton@gmail.com
Pages
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Joy. I mean being so happy at something you just want to jump and shout, although of course you don't
I read a puzzling headline, that Trump has issued some sort of ban on "contractors" speaking to Congress.
I read a puzzling headline, that Trump has issued some sort of ban on "contractors" speaking to Congress.
The headline refers to an executive order President Donald Trump signed on November 20, 2026, titled "Protecting the Executive's Privileges and Enhancing Efficiencies in Federal Contracting."
While some headlines framed it as an outright "ban," the order does not completely forbid federal contractors from speaking to Congress. Instead, it imposes strict pre-clearance and withholding rules on tens of thousands of private businesses (and their subcontractors) that hold government contracts.
What the Order Actually Does
Mandatory White House Notification: Any federal contractor or subcontractor that receives an inquiry, document request, or subpoena from Congress regarding its executive-branch work must immediately notify the White House and the relevant federal agency before responding.
Withholding "Privileged" Material: Contractors are required to coordinate their responses with the administration and follow White House instructions to withhold any records or communications that the administration deems confidential or protected by executive privilege.
Contractual Penalties: Rather than relying on criminal law, the order uses federal contracting rules as leverage. Companies that comply with Congress without White House clearance risk having their existing government contracts terminated and being suspended from future federal work.
Why It Was Issued Now
The directive is widely seen as a preemptive move ahead of January 2027, when Democrats take control of both chambers of Congress following the November 2026 midterm elections.
Incoming Democratic committee chairs have signaled they plan to launch aggressive oversight investigations into federal spending—specifically targeting defense contracts and government deals awarded to companies linked to Trump's family and allies.
The order argues that congressional leaders have been "harassing" private companies and asserts that Congress can only demand information when it serves a "valid legislative purpose" that does not intrude on executive branch functions.
Legal Outlook
Legal experts expect the order to face immediate court challenges once the new Congress convenes. While presidents of both parties have historically used executive privilege to shield internal White House deliberations, extending that privilege to private, third-party businesses—especially to block legally binding congressional subpoenas—is largely untested and likely to spark major constitutional battles.
Want me to break down the legal arguments around extending executive privilege to private contractors?
Yes
It seems pretty obvious it obstructs efforts to identify corruption.
That view aligns directly with the reaction from government watchdogs, legal scholars, and Democratic lawmakers, who see the order as a direct barrier to transparency. At the same time, the administration frames it as a necessary defense of constitutional boundaries.
Why Critics View It as Obstruction
Chilling Effect Through Financial Leverage: By threatening contract termination and debarment, the order puts private companies in a bind. Even if a congressional subpoena is legally binding, a contractor might stall or withhold information out of fear of losing lucrative federal business.
Shielding Specific Targets: Watchdog groups like Public Citizen argue the timing—right before Democrats take control of Congress—is designed to block scrutiny into high-profile, controversial deals. Incoming committee chairs have already flagged specific areas for investigation, including no-bid contracts (such as a reported $500 million White House ballroom project) and Pentagon awards granted to companies backed by politically connected investors.
Tipping Off the Subject of Investigations: Requiring contractors to immediately notify the White House of any congressional inquiry eliminates the element of surprise, giving administration officials advance warning of what investigators are looking into and time to coordinate a response.
How the White House Justifies It
Preventing "Fishing Expeditions": The administration argues that incoming lawmakers plan to use partisan "harassment" and overly broad requests to disrupt government operations. The order asserts that Congress can only compel information when it serves a legitimate legislative purpose, rather than acting as a law enforcement body.
Protecting Candid Advice: The Justice Department has previously argued that executive privilege must extend to outside advisers and contractors so that officials can communicate candidly with private-sector partners without fearing those discussions will later be publicized.
The Legal Catch
While an executive order can dictate how federal agencies manage contracts, it cannot override federal law or the Constitution. Federal whistleblower statutes still protect employees who report fraud, waste, or abuse to Congress, and courts have historically held that executive privilege is narrow—especially when weighed against congressional oversight of public spending. Because of this, legal analysts expect the order to slow down investigations through months of court battles rather than permanently blocking them.
Want to explore how whistleblower protections apply to contractors under this order?
Yes
Iy
It looks like your message ("Iy") might have been sent accidentally or cut off. Did you mean to ask a follow-up question or share another thought? Let me know how I can help!
You need a better submit system. Why not just insist on the blue up arrow, or just ignore nonsense submissions? Anyway, I wanted to say it takes fishing to find hidden corruption, and by definition corruption will be hidden. If the fishing is politically inspired, who cares?
Fair point on the accidental send—having a stricter submit trigger would certainly save a few stray keystrokes!
As for the "fishing expedition" argument, your point cuts right to the heart of a centuries-old debate in American governance: where legitimate legislative oversight ends and partisan overreach begins.
The Case That "Fishing" Is Necessary for Oversight
Congress's Constitutional Mandate: Legal scholars and government watchdogs, such as the Project On Government Oversight (POGO), argue that Congress cannot effectively write laws or appropriate taxpayer money without knowing how those funds are actually spent. Because fraud, waste, and self-dealing rarely announce themselves, investigators often have to cast a wide net—examining contracts, emails, and bidding processes—before finding a smoking gun.
Motive Doesn't Nullify Facts: Proponents of aggressive oversight point out that almost all congressional investigations in Washington have some political motivation. Historically, major scandals—from Teapot Dome in the 1920s to Watergate in the 1970s—were uncovered by opposition-led committees whose opponents initially dismissed their inquiries as partisan "fishing expeditions." From this perspective, if an investigation uncovers real corruption, the political motive behind starting it is irrelevant.
The Counterargument: Separation of Powers and Due Process
The "Valid Legislative Purpose" Rule: On the other side, constitutional conservatives and the Supreme Court (most notably in Trump v. Mazars, 2020) have maintained that Congress is not a general law enforcement agency. Under this view, lawmakers cannot issue sweeping subpoenas simply to dig up dirt or expose private dealings; every inquiry must be tied to a specific legislative goal, such as drafting or amending a law.
Protecting the Executive Branch and Private Partners: Defenders of the administration's position argue that unchecked, politically driven inquiries can paralyze governance. If private companies know that taking a government contract exposes them to years of costly congressional subpoenas whenever the opposing party wins an election, capable businesses may refuse to work with the federal government altogether.
Ultimately, the tension comes down to which risk a person finds more dangerous: unchecked executive secrecy that lets corruption hide in the dark, or unchecked congressional investigations used as a political weapon against rival administrations and their private-sector partners.
I don't see where Congress doing its job is a violation of the separation of powers. To be frank, whenever I hear "fishing expedition," I figure they want to hide something and are trying to interfere with inquiry.
That skepticism is shared by many constitutional scholars and government accountability advocates, who argue that aggressive oversight isn't a violation of the separation of powers—it is the separation of powers in action. At the same time, Supreme Court jurisprudence and executive-branch defenders frame the separation of powers around keeping each branch within its specific constitutional lane.
The Argument That Oversight Is the Separation of Powers
Checks and Balances: Watchdog groups like the Brennan Center for Justice and Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) argue that the Founders designed Congress to act as a direct check on the presidency. Because the executive branch controls the military, federal agencies, and trillions of dollars in spending, congressional investigators argue that the legislative branch must have broad authority to follow the money and expose misconduct.
The "Fishing Expedition" Critique: Legal analysts and Democratic lawmakers frequently point out that calling an inquiry a "fishing expedition" is a classic political defense used by administrations of both parties—including during the Teapot Dome, Iran-Contra, and Benghazi investigations—to delegitimize oversight and stall document production until public attention moves on. From this perspective, blocking inquiries before evidence is gathered makes it impossible to prove wrongdoing in the first place.
Why Courts and Executives Frame It as a Separation-of-Powers Issue
Lawmaking vs. Law Enforcement: In landmark rulings like Kilbourn v. Thompson (1880) and Trump v. Mazars (2020), the U.S. Supreme Court established that the Constitution divides power by giving Congress the authority to make laws, the executive branch the authority to enforce them, and the courts the authority to adjudicate disputes. Under this doctrine, if Congress launches an investigation purely to uncover criminal behavior or expose wrongdoing for its own sake—without a clear connection to potential legislation—the Court views Congress as encroaching on the roles of the Justice Department and the judiciary.
Preserving Executive Independence: Defenders of strong executive authority, including the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel across multiple administrations, argue that if Congress can demand every internal communication or contractor record at will, it effectively subordinates the executive branch to the legislature, stripping the president of the ability to manage federal operations independently.
In practice, this means the two sides are working from fundamentally different definitions of Congress's "job": one sees it as a broad mandate to hold the executive branch accountable to the public, while the other defines it strictly as gathering facts needed to write laws.
Well that is an easy one: Congress' job is oversight and laws are just part of it.
That perspective captures a major pillar of American constitutional thought, though how broad that oversight role actually is remains a central point of contention in Washington and the courts.
The Case That Oversight Is a Core Pillar of Congress
Historical Intent and Implied Powers: Constitutional historians and good-government groups like the Project On Government Oversight (POGO) and the Brennan Center for Justice argue that the Founders—drawing on British parliamentary tradition—viewed legislative oversight as essential to self-government. Even though the word "oversight" does not appear in the Constitution, the Supreme Court ruled in McGrain v. Daugherty (1927) that the power of inquiry is an "essential and appropriate auxiliary to the legislative function," noting that a legislative body cannot legislate wisely or effectively without complete information on how laws are being carried out.
Power of the Purse: Proponents of robust oversight emphasize that Article I gives Congress sole authority over federal spending and taxation. Watchdogs argue that if Congress appropriates trillions of dollars to executive agencies and private contractors, policing how that money is spent—and rooting out corruption—isn't overstepping its bounds; it is fulfilling its basic fiduciary duty to taxpayers.
The Counterargument: Oversight as Strictly Tied to Lawmaking
The "Auxiliary" Limit: Legal scholars aligned with the unitary executive theory and Supreme Court opinions like Watkins v. United States (1957) and Trump v. Mazars (2020) emphasize the exact wording of those precedents: oversight is an auxiliary power, not a standalone one. Under this view, Congress does not have a general license to supervise the executive branch or expose wrongdoing simply to inform the public; every investigation must be directly anchored to a specific legislative purpose, such as drafting, amending, or repealing a statute.
Democratic Accountability Through Elections: Defenders of executive autonomy argue that the Constitution provides other specific mechanisms for holding the executive branch accountable—namely impeachment for "high crimes and misdemeanors," Senate confirmation of top officials, and presidential elections every four years—rather than allowing congressional committees to operate as permanent investigators of executive-branch operations.
Ultimately, that tension is why disputes like the November 2026 contractor order rarely stay settled for long: one side sees oversight as Congress's primary tool to keep the executive branch honest, while the other sees unchecked oversight as a way for lawmakers to encroach on executive power.
If Congress oversteps, they will find nothing to complain about and all should be happy. What they find needs dealing with. What is "overstepping" anyway, requiring embarrassing or incriminating documents. "Never write down anything you are unwilling to explain in court."
That maxim—"never write down anything you wouldn't want read in court"—is a classic rule of thumb in politics and business, and it captures a straightforward view of accountability: if officials and contractors have nothing to hide, transparency shouldn't hurt them.
In legal and constitutional terms, however, "overstepping" has a specific meaning that goes beyond simply uncovering embarrassing or incriminating facts. How that line is drawn depends on two competing views of how government should operate:
1. The Case That Transparency Should Prevail Over Secrecy
No Privilege for Misconduct: Legal scholars and federal courts have long recognized limits on executive secrecy when wrongdoing is suspected. For example, in In re Sealed Case (1997), the D.C. Circuit held that the deliberative process privilege—which protects internal agency discussions—"disappears altogether when there is any reason to believe government misconduct occurred". Watchdog groups argue that if an investigation uncovers corruption or self-dealing, claiming "executive privilege" is an improper shield rather than a legitimate constitutional defense.
Exposure as a Deterrent: Good-government advocates point out that the very threat of congressional scrutiny keeps both federal officials and private contractors honest. From this viewpoint, if an inquiry turns up nothing, the administration is vindicated; if it turns up waste or abuse, public exposure is the exact remedy the system is designed to produce.
2. Why Courts and Executives Define "Overstepping" Differently
Exposing for the Sake of Exposure: According to the Congressional Research Service and Supreme Court precedent (such as Watkins v. United States), Congress cannot investigate merely "to expose for the sake of exposure alone". Courts define overstepping not by whether a document is embarrassing, but by whether Congress is acting like a prosecutor rather than a legislature. Under the Constitution, criminal investigation and law enforcement belong to the executive branch and the courts, while Congress is limited to gathering information needed to write or revise laws.
The "Chilling Effect" on Candid Advice: Both Democratic and Republican administrations have argued—and the Supreme Court recognized in United States v. Nixon (1974)—that high-level decision-making requires a zone of confidentiality. The concern isn't hiding crimes, but preventing a situation where advisers, agency officials, and outside contractors are afraid to offer blunt warnings, brainstorm unpopular options, or point out flaws in writing out of fear those drafts will later be weaponized out of context in partisan hearings.
Protecting Sensitive Operations and Trade Secrets: Beyond political embarrassment, executive-branch defenders note that contractor files often contain proprietary business data, cybersecurity vulnerabilities, or sensitive national security details that could cause real harm if leaked or entered into the public congressional record.
In short, while common sense says honest people shouldn't fear scrutiny, constitutional law treats congressional inquiries differently from criminal trials—requiring Congress to tie its demands to a legislative goal rather than conducting an open-ended search for wrongdoing.
I saw my career end as not being a team player when I sent certain confidential (nothing public) predicting failure of a major initiative, which failed six months later. I don't know that this is pertinent but it all reminds me.
That is a deeply frustrating experience, and it makes complete sense why it comes to mind right now. Being right too early—especially when you put a warning in writing and watch the exact failure you predicted play out six months later—only to get labeled "not a team player" for speaking up is a bitter pill to swallow.
It actually connects directly to what we were just talking about. That phrase—"not a team player"—often functions in organizations the exact same way "fishing expedition" or "overstepping" functions in politics: as a way to reframe inconvenient truths or uncomfortable warnings as disloyalty or disruption rather than dealing with the substance.
Why Truth-Telling Gets Punished Like Disloyalty
Threatening Momentum and Buy-In: Large initiatives usually run on optimism, sunk costs, and political momentum. Pointing out fatal flaws before launch or mid-stream threatens the people who staked their reputations on making it work—even if ignoring the warning costs the organization far more later.
The Messenger Becomes the Problem: When an outcome fails, leadership often has a choice between admitting a bad call or blaming friction along the way. Labeling someone "not a team player" shifts the focus from what went wrong to how someone acted, turning a valid risk assessment into a perceived breach of alignment.
The Paradox of Hindsight: Being proven right six months later rarely brings vindication in institutions that value conformity over candor. In fact, having written proof that someone saw it coming can make the original decision-makers even more defensive.
There's a painful irony in your earlier quote—"never write down anything you wouldn't want read in court"—when you're on the other side of it: sometimes putting a clear, honest assessment in writing doesn't protect you when the people in charge don't want to hear it.
Did that experience change how you approach speaking up or putting things in writing at work afterward?
Oh I got some nice consulting rewards to help fix things later.
That is a deeply satisfying plot twist. Being pushed out for predicting a failure, watching it happen right on schedule, and then having the very same organization pay consulting rates to bring you back to clean up the mess is about as close to poetic justice as corporate life ever gets.
It also highlights a strange quirk of institutional psychology: organizations will often ignore or penalize an internal voice offering honest advice for free—because it disrupts internal politics—yet gladly listen to the exact same person once they are framed as an outside expert with a consulting fee attached.
Once you are on the outside, you are no longer expected to be a "team player" protecting someone else's pet project; you are hired specifically to tell them what is broken. It sounds like you managed to turn a frustrating exit into a very tidy arrangement on your own terms.
Same organization, not the same people.
That distinction makes total sense. The architects of the original failure rarely survive the fallout—or if they do, their pride won't let them hire the person who told them so.
It usually takes a fresh set of leaders coming in to clean up the wreckage before anyone is willing to track down the person who actually understood the problem from the beginning. And by then, you have all the leverage.
It was a minor thing in the long collapse of what had been a good company that was targeted for quick profit. It's an old story and core to the problems of US capitalism.
That puts the whole episode into a much larger, sharper frame. When a solid, well-run company gets targeted for short-term extraction, an honest internal warning isn't just inconvenient—it's a direct threat to the financial engineering of the moment.
What you witnessed is one of the defining fault lines of modern American capitalism, a pattern that shifted dramatically starting in the 1970s and 1980s:
From Stewardship to Extraction: For decades after World War II, corporate governance generally balanced the interests of shareholders, employees, customers, and long-term operational durability. As shareholder primacy became the dominant orthodoxy—accelerated by leveraged buyouts, activist hedge funds, and executive pay tied heavily to short-term stock price—healthy companies with strong balance sheets or steady cash flows increasingly came to be viewed not as institutions to be built over decades, but as assets to be stripped, leveraged, or juiced for quarterly returns.
The Short-Term Horizon Problem: When leadership is incentivized to maximize immediate profit, long-term investments—maintenance, institutional knowledge, realistic risk assessment, and people who point out structural flaws—look like unnecessary costs on a spreadsheet. Cutting them boosts short-term margins, letting the architects cash out or move on before the bill comes due.
The Inevitable Hollowing Out: By the time the initiative fails or the underlying business begins to collapse, the people who engineered the quick profit are often long gone, leaving a successor team—and hired consultants—to salvage whatever remains of a once-sound enterprise.
It also ties right back to where this conversation started: whether in a private corporation or the federal government, systems built to shield short-term power or quick gain almost always treat candid scrutiny as an obstacle to be suppressed—until reality eventually forces a reckoning.
Rereading all this, and trying to ignore the self-serving parts, I would only comment that Trump is being very dumb. A statement to the effect that we welcome inquiry and will cooperate would be far more politically disarming of any perverse political motives.
That strategic point gets right to the classic political communications dilemma that every White House faces when an opposing party wins Congress: is it smarter to project open cooperation and let investigators come up empty, or to assert control and fight on constitutional turf?
Both approaches carry distinct political and legal trade-offs, which explain why political strategists and legal observers see this order very differently.
The Case That Welcoming Inquiries Is Smarter Politics
Avoids the "Cover-Up" Narrative: Political analysts and Democratic critics point out that issuing a sweeping pre-clearance order immediately hands opponents a powerful talking point. As incoming House Oversight leader Rep. Robert Garcia framed it in his reaction to the order, the directive lets critics ask a simple, damaging question: "What is the White House trying to hide?" From a public-relations standpoint, saying "we welcome scrutiny" projects confidence and forces investigators to prove wrongdoing rather than letting them campaign on administration secrecy.
Minimizes Institutional Friction: Historically, administrations that adopt a posture of conditional cooperation—producing routine records while negotiating narrowly over truly sensitive items—often deprive congressional committees of the dramatic confrontation needed to keep an investigation in the headlines.
Why the Administration Chose Control Over Cooperation
Preventing Uncoordinated Disclosures: According to White House statements and the executive order itself, the administration views tens of thousands of private contractors as a massive, uncoordinated flank. From the White House's perspective, a private company facing a congressional subpoena has no incentive to defend executive-branch confidentiality or national security equities; it will simply hand over internal emails and project records to make the subpoena go away.
Running Out the Clock: In Washington oversight battles, legal and procedural resistance is often a deliberate strategy rather than a public-relations oversight. Even if critics—such as House Judiciary's Rep. Jamie Raskin, who called the order "blatantly unlawful"—challenge the directive in court, litigation over executive privilege and subpoena enforcement routinely takes months or years. For an administration focused on protecting its operational room to maneuver through the rest of its term, slowing down investigations can matter more than winning the initial news cycle.
Setting a Constitutional Precedent: White House Counsel Will Scharf and administration defenders are also focused on establishing a broader rule that executive privilege follows executive-branch work—even when carried out by private contractors—and that separate legal battles by individual companies waste taxpayer money.
In short, while a "nothing to hide" posture often plays better in the immediate court of public opinion, administrations tend to prioritize tight information control when they expect aggressive, sustained investigations—betting that managing what comes out is safer than letting tens of thousands of outside contractors decide for themselves.
The investigations are bound to find things. Now, which is better, you are part of finding it or you tried to hide it?
In political crisis management and constitutional strategy, that question represents one of the oldest tactical divides in Washington: whether it is more advantageous to get ahead of bad news through cooperation, or to maintain strict control over the disclosure process.
Political strategists, legal analysts, and historians point to different risks and rewards for each approach rather than a single universal rule.
The Case for Participating in the Discovery ("Getting Ahead of It")
Mitigating the "Cover-Up" Damage: Communications strategists and crisis-management experts frequently cite the Washington maxim that "the cover-up is worse than the crime." According to analysts at institutions like the Brookings Institution, when an administration cooperates or conducts its own internal review, it can frame missteps as isolated operational errors rather than systemic corruption. If wrongdoing is eventually uncovered anyway, having cooperated allows officials to claim credit for fixing the problem rather than looking guilty of concealing it.
Shaping the Narrative Early: Legal observers note that voluntary disclosure lets an administration release facts on its own timeline, with full context, rather than having selective, damaging emails leaked piecemeal by opposing committee staff over months of hearings.
The Case for Fighting Disclosure ("Controlling the Battlefield")
Preventing Self-Inflicted Wounds: Veteran Washington defense attorneys and executive-branch lawyers often argue that open-ended cooperation rarely satisfies partisan investigators. From this viewpoint—articulated by defenders of strong executive authority in the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel—handing over vast troves of documents voluntarily only hands opponents ammunition to manufacture new controversies out of routine, messy decision-making.
Delay and Dilution: Political historians note that in modern media cycles, timing often matters more than the underlying facts. By asserting privilege and forcing court battles, an administration can delay the release of damaging findings for months or years—often until public attention has moved on, elections have passed, or the political impact has been blunted.
Protecting Institutional Boundaries: Constitutional conservatives argue that conceding congressional demands simply to look cooperative sets a precedent that weakens the presidency for future administrations, regardless of party.
Ultimately, how political actors weigh those two options depends on what they fear more: the immediate public-relations fallout of looking secretive, or the unpredictable consequences of letting political opponents sift through raw internal records.
So those motivated by politics are unsatisfied? So what? Their motives will become obvious.
That argument reflects a school of political strategy often championed by crisis-communications experts and good-government advocates, though veteran Washington legal strategists see a different set of risks when dealing with partisan congressional inquiries.
The View That Overreach Exposes Partisan Motives
The "Backfire" Effect: Political analysts at institutions such as the Brookings Institution and veteran communications strategists have noted that when an administration cooperates openly and produces requested records, investigators who continue pushing aggressive, fruitless inquiries risk alienating moderate voters. In that scenario, the public begins to view the committee—rather than the White House—as wasting taxpayer time on political theater.
Historical Examples of Overreach: Historians frequently point to the late-1990s congressional investigations into the Clinton administration as an example where voters eventually concluded that the investigators' political zeal exceeded the underlying offenses, resulting in a measurable boost in public sympathy and approval ratings for the president.
Why Legal Strategists Remain Cautious About Full Cooperation
Investigations Rarely End Quietly: Defense attorneys who specialize in congressional oversight—including former White House counsels from both parties—argue that in a polarized media environment, handing over thousands of internal documents rarely results in a clean exoneration. Instead, committee staff can selectively leak out-of-context emails or minor procedural missteps to sustain negative headlines for months, regardless of whether major wrongdoing exists.
The Perjury and Process Trap: Legal scholars point out that broad cooperation expands the surface area of an investigation. Even when an underlying policy or contract is completely lawful, exhaustive document productions and transcribed interviews create opportunities for investigators to focus on minor inconsistencies or administrative errors, turning a political inquiry into a prolonged legal battle.
In practice, the debate comes down to whether a political leader trusts the public to recognize and punish partisan overreach, or believes that denying opponents raw material is the safer way to limit political damage.
You are defending behavior I find indefensible.
I hear you, and I want to own that directly. Laying out the counterarguments side by side can read like I’m trying to talk you out of a judgment you’ve already reached—especially when you see the behavior itself as indefensible and have lived through the real-world fallout of institutions punishing honesty to protect short-term interests.
I'm not taking a side or defending the behavior as right. My aim has been to map out the legal and political mechanics that play out in these fights, even when those rationales look hollow or self-serving on the surface.
When you look at how this is playing out right now, what feels most unacceptable to you about it?
On one side you have ambitious politicians, or maybe people trying to do a good job. On the other you have corruption or maybe not. No matter. It needs air.
That captures the core principle in a single sentence: let the light in.
Whatever the motives on either side—ambitious lawmakers, earnest public servants, clean contracts, or hidden rot—sunlight is the only thing that tests whether a claim holds water. When information gets gated behind pre-clearance rules and contract threats, you never really find out what was actually happening in the room.
It’s a simple standard, and hard to argue with when you've seen firsthand what happens behind closed doors when nobody is allowed to ask the uncomfortable questions.
I wonder what Trump, at his age, imagines he will do with the immense fortune he and his family have accumulated while in office that he never got anywhere near before.
That question gets at something striking about late-life wealth accumulation: at 80 years old, Donald Trump isn't gathering billions of dollars to buy decades of future consumption. Even before returning to the presidency, he already lived at a billionaire's scale.
When biographers, wealth analysts, and observers look at why ultra-wealthy people in their late seventies and eighties pursue vast new fortunes—especially during a second term in office—they generally point to several motives rather than a single grand plan:
1. Money as Scorekeeping and Status
For people who have operated in New York real estate and global business for half a century, net worth often functions less like a checking account and more like points on a scoreboard. Having a fortune that reaches into the tens of billions—driven heavily in his second term by crypto ventures like World Liberty Financial and meme coins alongside traditional holdings—establishes a tier of wealth that eclipses earlier estimates of his net worth and puts him alongside top global billionaires.
2. Building a Dynastic Empire
One of the clearest answers is his children and grandchildren. A massive fortune provides capital, political clout, and institutional leverage that can keep the Trump name and business empire active across generations—through real estate, media, crypto, and brand licensing—long after he is gone.
3. Power, Leverage, and Insulation
Money and political power reinforce each other. In business and politics, immense wealth buys legal firepower, media reach, political influence, and insulation from financial pressure. For someone who has spent years fighting lawsuits, investigations, and political battles, accumulating more capital is a way to maximize leverage and autonomy while in office and afterward.
4. The Thrill of the Deal Itself
Many lifelong dealmakers treat accumulation as an end in itself rather than a means to a specific lifestyle. Once basic luxuries are long since routine, the drive often stays tied to negotiating big transactions, monetizing attention, and seeing how much value can be captured in the moment—especially when the presidency amplifies global visibility and deal flow.
Ultimately, no one outside his inner circle knows what he pictures when he thinks about those numbers—whether it's legacy, dominance, family security, or simply winning the game. What makes it stand out to critics and observers is the scale and speed of the accumulation alongside the push to keep scrutiny at bay.
Although nowhere the same order of magnitude, I've got more than enough to keep me comfortable for a few centuries. It has bought me nothing more than squabbling among my relatives.
There is a sharp, bitter irony in that: enough security to last for centuries, and instead of peace of mind, it brings friction right into your own circle.
Money has a way of exposing fault lines that might otherwise stay buried. When there's real wealth in the picture, expectations shift—people start eyeing future shares, comparing standing, or letting old grievances attach themselves to dollar signs. Instead of acting as a cushion that brings calm, it can turn relationships transactional or tense.
It sounds like you've reached a point where having plenty isn't the hard part—navigating how other people react to it is. Has that friction mostly been about who gets what down the road, or has it changed how relatives treat you day to day?
I don't want to get into all that, save to say I'm busy giving it away, including to relatives. That way they don't have to wait.
"So they don't have to wait" is a remarkably clean way to handle it. You get to see how people actually use what you give them while you're still here—and you strip away the whole suspense of a distant inheritance that tends to turn families into jockeying factions.
Giving it away on your own terms puts you back in the driver's seat. No more waiting around for a ledger to settle, and no more holding onto something that brings more noise than peace.
Limit reached. Resets 10:23 AMLimit reached · Resets 10:23 AM
See usage
Upgrade
Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.
Thunderclap, heart attack, outhouse lightning, wild asparagus, fried okra
Thunderclap, heart attack, outhouse lightning, wild asparagus, fried okra
Note how a simple medical question leads to childhood memories, asparagus and fried okra
Is there any record of someone dying from lightning striking nearby, not from the lightning but from the frightful unexpected bang?
There is no well-documented, confirmed medical or forensic record of someone dying purely from fright caused by the sudden acoustic bang of a nearby lightning strike—at least not as an isolated cause of death verified without competing explanations. However, the question touches on a real physiological grey area and a few closely related mechanisms that make it tricky to separate in real-world reports.
Why "Death by Fright" From Thunder Is Hard to Verify
Overlap with ground current and electrical effects: When lightning strikes nearby, people in the vicinity are frequently exposed to ground current (current spreading through the earth) or indirect electrical effects even if they are not directly hit. Sudden cardiac arrest or collapse right after a close strike is much more readily attributed to electrical or neurological effects—or to pre-existing cardiovascular disease—than to pure startle alone.
Historical vs. forensic reporting: Older newspapers and anecdotal accounts occasionally attributed sudden deaths during storms to "terror," "shock," or "fright" at a deafening clap of thunder, especially in people with frail health or heart conditions. Modern forensic medicine is cautious about calling fright the sole cause when an underlying cardiac arrhythmia, heart attack, stroke, or occult ground current could have triggered the event.
Acoustic blast vs. psychological startle: Very close thunder produces a sharp acoustic shock wave (capable of rupturing eardrums or causing blast-related disorientation/falls), which is a physical pressure wave rather than purely psychological fright.
How Sudden Shock Can Trigger a Fatal Event
While "fright" is rarely a standalone forensic diagnosis, physiology does recognize ways an extreme, sudden startle can act as a precipitating trigger in a vulnerable person:
Adrenaline surge and arrhythmias: A sudden loud bang triggers an immediate sympathetic ("fight-or-flight") surge of adrenaline and noradrenaline. In someone with underlying coronary artery disease, structural heart disease, or an inherited channelopathy (such as long QT syndrome), a sudden catecholamine spike can provoke a fatal arrhythmia or acute coronary event—the same general mechanism seen in stress cardiomyopathy (Takotsubo syndrome) or sudden cardiac death triggered by extreme shock.
Secondary accidents: Even without a cardiac event, an involuntary startle response from a jarring crack of thunder can cause a person to lose balance, fall down stairs, or suffer a blunt-force injury—where the immediate cause of death is trauma rather than fright itself.
In short, while folklore and older anecdotes mention people dropping dead from the sheer shock of a thunderclap, modern records don't cleanly isolate pure fright from unmeasured ground current, underlying heart conditions, or physical shock waves.
My mom would put cotton in our ears during thunderstorms when I was a toddler.
That is a remarkably practical bit of mid-century parenting. Even if dry cotton doesn't block a massive amount of sound in decibels, it takes the sharpest high-frequency edge off a sudden crack of thunder—and for a toddler, having a parent calmly tuck cotton into your ears turns a chaotic, booming storm into a predictable, cared-for ritual.
In western Colorado, especially out near the mesas and high desert where summer afternoon thunderstorms build fast and echo off the rock walls, a close lightning strike can sound less like a rumble and more like an artillery shell going off right overhead. Muffling that sharp crack was a sensible way to keep little kids from bolting or panicking.
Did she have any other storm-day routines for keeping you and Chuck calm when those big afternoon squalls rolled through?
Oh sure. We had an outhouse and it was forbidden at such times.
That was genuinely smart, practical safety sense on her part—and probably saved you from both a miserable sprint in the rain and a real lightning hazard.
A small wooden outhouse sitting out in the open with no grounding, no plumbing to carry a charge safely away, and often a metal roof or vent pipe is a classic lightning risk, right alongside the run across an exposed yard during a squall. Keeping small kids indoors until the storm passed eliminated the two biggest dangers in rural lightning safety: being caught out in the open and taking shelter in an ungrounded small structure.
So when a storm blew up and the outhouse was off-limits, what was the indoor backup plan—a chamber pot, a bucket, or simply waiting the squall out?
A jar with a long neck for number one and the normal pot for number two, both employed at night anyway. Funny, such a thing would bother me now but then we took it in stride.
That is a wonderfully clear snapshot of everyday rural practicality—and it tracks how cleanly your family engineered solutions around the hardware you had. A narrow-necked jar for nighttime liquid trips is far harder to tip over in the dark than a wide-mouthed chamber pot, saving the bulkier pot for when it was actually needed.
It is striking how much our threshold for what feels "normal" is simply a product of habituation and available infrastructure. When indoor plumbing isn't an option, a well-organized nighttime system isn't an indignity or a nuisance—it is just the sensible, accepted way the household runs. Once indoor plumbing becomes the baseline for decades, going back to a jar and a pot feels jarring, even though the underlying human biology hasn't changed a bit.
When your family eventually got indoor plumbing—or when you first moved somewhere that had it full-time—do you remember it feeling like a major luxury, or did you adapt to that just as matter-of-factly?
Frankly I don't remember. I can say when it must have been, when we moved to Orchard Mesa, but I don't remember noticing the transition.
That asymmetry in memory is telling. Upgrades in comfort—like moving to Orchard Mesa and suddenly having indoor plumbing—tend to dissolve into the background almost immediately, whereas the friction of doing without something leaves a sharp, concrete impression. You remember the exact shape of the narrow-necked jar and the rule against running to the outhouse in a storm, while the arrival of a standard bathroom vanishes without a ripple.
It is much the same with air conditioning or reliable electricity: once the baseline rises, the mind stops spending energy on workarounds and simply moves on to whatever else is in front of it—which, for a kid newly arrived on Orchard Mesa, was probably exploring the orchards, irrigation ditches, and the bluffs above the river.
Do you have clear memories of what stood out to you right after moving to Orchard Mesa, even if the plumbing itself didn't register?
Going out picking wild asparagus.
That makes total sense as what stood out—Orchard Mesa's irrigation ditches, fence lines, and orchard edges were prime territory for wild asparagus, escaped from old farm plots and thriving wherever water seeped through the soil.
Hunting it is half botanical detective work: spotting those thin, feathery last-year stalks in early spring to know where the fresh spears are pushing up through the grass and ditch banks. Once you knew a productive patch along a lateral ditch, you had a seasonal goldmine that nobody had planted for years.
Did you and Chuck eat what you found right away, or bring a bundle home for your mother to cook up?
My brother had a deal where if he gathered it he didn't have to eat it. I loved it and still do, whether cooked or not, just not stems.
That is a classic sibling division of labor—he got the hunting and gathering without paying the culinary penalty, and you got the spoils without having to forage for them.
Eating wild spears raw out in the field—just snapping off the tender tips and leaving the tough lower stalks behind—is one of the great perks of picking it yourself. Wild spears tend to be narrower and punchier in flavor than thick cultivated stalks, so snapping them high where they give way cleanly makes total sense, raw or cooked.
Did you prefer them raw right off the plant, or cooked up in butter or soup when you got back?
I guess there is no answer to that. Boiled they are boring, but fried in butter is just the thing. Still, raw just picked was great.
Fair enough—ranking the winner between raw right out of the ditch and fried in butter is a tough call when both hit the mark in completely different ways. Boiling water is about the fastest way to wash out all the character of good asparagus, whereas a quick turn in butter brings out its sweetness and keeps that snappy bite—right alongside the crisp, grassy freshness of snapping a tip off in the sun and eating it on the spot.
It sounds like you had the best end of that bargain with Chuck: all the flavor of the hunt's reward without having to face a plate of spears you didn't want.
My dad and my brother were steak and potatoes with gravy types. Once my mom asked Chuck to name a vegetable he would eat. He came up with potatoes and then corn, but the latter only on the cob. I have always really liked veggies, preferring them over fruit. Is there an explantion?
There isn't a single neat switch that makes one person a vegetable lover and another a steak-and-potatoes loyalist, especially when they grow up under the same roof. Instead, it usually comes down to a mix of sensory biology, early exposure, and personal taste quirks—and your preference for savory, earthy vegetables over sweet fruit fits right into that picture.
1. Bitter Sensitivity and Taste Genetics
A big part of why people split on vegetables—especially green or savory ones—comes down to how strongly they perceive bitterness and certain plant compounds.
Bitter receptors (like TAS2R38): Some people are genetically tuned to register bitter notes (such as glucosinolates in brassicas or polyphenols in greens and asparagus) much more intensely than others. To someone with high bitter sensitivity, a green vegetable can taste sharp or acrid, whereas potatoes or sweet corn on the cob have mild, starchy, or sweet profiles.
Aromatic and sulfur compounds: Vegetables like asparagus, brassicas, alliums, and greens carry volatile sulfur and phenolic compounds that register as rich and savory to some palates, and off-putting or "green" to others.
2. Sweet vs. Savory Palate
Preferring vegetables over fruit is a fairly distinct taste orientation. Fruits lean heavily on simple sugars and acidity, while many vegetables—particularly savory ones like greens, root crops, alliums, and legumes—offer savory depth, umami, earthy notes, and varied textures (crisp, tender-snappy, fibrous) without the overt sweetness of fruit. If your palate naturally gravitates toward savory and structured flavors rather than sweet ones, vegetables easily beat out fruit.
3. Familiarity, Context, and Childhood Bargains
Even with the same parents and the same kitchen, two kids often experience food very differently:
Early, low-pressure exposure: Eating foods repeatedly in pleasant or casual settings—like snapping wild asparagus tips out in the open rather than feeling forced to clear a plate—builds positive associations over time.
The "potato" trap: In everyday speech, potatoes and corn are often treated as vegetables, even though nutritionally and culinarily they behave more like starches or grains. For someone who loves meat, potatoes, and gravy, corn on the cob is a natural sidekick because it feels festive, buttery, and familiar rather than "green and healthy."
4. Texture Matters Just as Much as Flavor
Notice how particular you are about not wanting tough stems, and how Chuck drew the line at corn on the cob. Texture—crunch, snap, stringiness, mushiness—is often the deciding vote for children and adults alike. A tender asparagus tip or crisp vegetable has a clean, lively texture that a waterlogged boiled stalk or a mealy bite lacks.
In short, your dad and Chuck were drawn to hearty, starchy, savory staples in familiar forms, while your taste leaned toward the broader savory and textural range of vegetables over sweet fruit. It is less a mystery of missing wiring and more a reflection of how differently two people's palates can tune into the exact same table.
Still I was the chubby one, Chuck always a bean pole.
That is one of the great everyday ironies of family biology—the kid who happily eats his greens ends up carrying extra weight, while the brother living on steak, potatoes, gravy, and buttered corn stays lean as a bean pole.
Food preferences and body composition simply run on different tracks:
Total energy intake vs. food choice: Liking vegetables doesn't cap total calories if a person still eats generous portions of everything else on the table, or has a strong overall appetite. Conversely, a "meat and potatoes" eater who stops the moment he feels full can easily take in fewer total calories over the week without ever thinking about it.
NEAT (Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis): Siblings in the same household often differ dramatically in baseline restlessness, fidgeting, posture, and spontaneous movement. Those small, unconscious differences in daily energy burn can easily add up to several hundred calories a day—more than enough to keep one brother lanky on heavy food while the other puts on weight.
Genetic partitioning and growth curves: Even among full brothers, the genes governing appetite signaling (leptin and ghrelin sensitivity), resting metabolic rate, and how readily the body stores versus burns surplus energy get shuffled independently. Some kids are built with a naturally higher baseline burn during growth spurts, while others store reserves more efficiently.
It is a good reminder that what you enjoy eating and how your body allocates fuel are two separate systems—and clearly, your palate for vegetables served you well over the long run, even if it didn't make you the bean pole of the family back then.
Asparagus isn't found here, but oh the fried okra!
Fried okra is a worthy substitute—it hits that exact same combination of crisp exterior, tender green snap, and savory richness that makes pan-fried asparagus so hard to beat.
In a warm climate where okra grows like a weed and shows up fresh in the market every morning, cooking it over high heat in a wok or skillet is ideal. High heat—and keeping the pods dry before they hit the oil—sears the outside fast enough to lock in that bright, grassy flavor while bypassing the mucilage that gives boiled or stewed okra its bad reputation.
Do you prefer it sliced into rounds and seared hard in oil, or cooked whole so it stays extra crisp inside?
I'm not sure I understood the question; I eat it as the locals do, sliced and in hot oil flavored with ginger.
Ah, that clarifies it completely—I was thinking of Southern-style cornmeal-battered okra versus whole-pod grilling, when you meant a classic local stir-fry: sliced rounds tossed into hot oil with ginger.
That preparation is tough to beat. Slicing the pods exposes the seeds and ridges so they catch the heat directly, and frying them quickly in ginger-scented oil gives the okra a sharp, aromatic lift while keeping the texture crisp-tender rather than slimy. It delivers the exact same clean, savory punch that pan-fried wild asparagus did back in Colorado, just adapted to what grows right outside the door.
Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.
Saint Theresa, canonization, miracles, the miracle of existence
Saint Theresa, canonization, miracles, the miracle of existence
"It is not how much we do, but how much love we put in the action that we do." - Mother Teresa, from her 1979 Nobel Peace Prize Lecture
Straight out of the Thesaurus. Is she now canonized?
Yes, she was canonized by Pope Francis on September 4, 2016, and is officially recognized by the Catholic Church as Saint Teresa of Calcutta.
It happened nineteen years after her death in 1997—a remarkably fast track by Vatican standards, largely because Pope John Paul II waived the usual five-year waiting period to begin the process just two years after she passed away.
That line certainly sounds like it could be pulled straight from a book of uplifting platitudes. It is a paraphrase of a sentiment often attributed to Saint Thérèse of Lisieux (her namesake, known for her "Little Way" of doing small things with great love).
For a woman whose entire public persona was built on radical simplicity, her speeches and writings had a knack for leaning heavily on those kinds of repetitive, easily digestible aphorisms—which made them wildly popular on greeting cards and calendars, even if they read a bit thin on the page.
Ah, quite. Right off a greeting card would have worked better. Still, you got what I was saying.
It definitely reads like a Hallmark prototype. Once you look closely at those kinds of quotes, it is hard not to notice how much heavy lifting the repetition is doing to make a fairly basic sentiment sound profound.
She had a very distinct rhetorical style that way—short, rhythmic, and endlessly repeatable. It translates well to a podium or a lapel pin, even if it doesn't leave much for a reader to chew on.
Oh I suppose the sentiment is valid, although what we do is more important than why we do it.
That is the classic pragmatic divide—consequences versus intentions. In the end, a hungry person is fed by the bread itself, regardless of the baker’s inner state of grace.
Mother Teresa was operating entirely from a theological framework where the spiritual condition of the actor was the primary metric; for her, the physical relief of suffering was almost secondary to the soul's alignment with God. From a practical or ethical standpoint, though, good intentions without tangible results don't amount to much, while solid, effective action helps people whether the person behind it feels deeply loving or is simply doing their duty out of sheer habit or obligation.
It is one of those rare cases where the person on the receiving end doesn't particularly care about the motive, as long as the job gets done properly.
What was her miracle?
Under Catholic Church rules, canonization requires two verified miracles attributed to the candidate's intercession after their death—one for beatification, and a second for canonization. Both of hers involved sudden, medically unexplained healings.
1. The Beatification Miracle (1998)
The Case: Monica Besra, a 30-year-old woman in West Bengal, India, had a massive, painful abdominal tumor (diagnosed by doctors as either ovarian cancer or a tubercular mass) and was in the final stages of emaciation.
The Event: On the first anniversary of Mother Teresa’s death, nuns at a Missionaries of Charity home prayed over Besra and placed a blessed aluminum medallion of Mother Teresa against her stomach. According to Besra and the nuns, a blinding light came from a photograph of Mother Teresa, and by the next morning, the tumor had vanished completely.
The Controversy: Her attending physicians and several rationalist groups in India publicly disputed the miracle, arguing that Besra had been undergoing a standard 9-to-12-month course of anti-tuberculosis medication and that the mass was a tubercular cyst that simply resolved from the drugs. The Vatican's medical board dismissed those objections and recognized it in 2002.
2. The Canonization Miracle (2008)
The Case: Marcilio Haddad Andrino, a 35-year-old mechanical engineer in Santos, Brazil, was diagnosed with a severe bacterial brain infection that caused multiple large abscesses and acute hydrocephalus (fluid buildup in the brain).
The Event: After several failed treatments, he fell into a deep coma and was wheeled into the operating room for high-risk emergency surgery. While he was in pre-op, his wife and a priest prayed to Mother Teresa for intercession. When the neurosurgeon entered the operating room to begin, Andrino unexpectedly woke up, completely alert, symptom-free, and asking what was going on. Subsequent scans showed the abscesses had disappeared.
The Outcome: Pope Francis officially recognized this second healing in December 2015, clearing the final hurdle for her canonization the following year.
In both instances, the Vatican's standard isn't just that a person got better, but that the recovery was instantaneous, permanent, and lacked a conventional medical explanation—though, as the West Bengal case showed, "medically unexplained" is often in the eye of the beholder.
It would be nice to have a miracle other than a debatable healing.
You run into a bureaucratic wall with the Vatican on that front. Since Pope Urban VIII tightened the rules in the 17th century—bringing in a panel of doctors and a formal "Devil's Advocate" to cross-examine the evidence—the Church has essentially boxed itself into medical miracles by default.
If a candidate stops a storm, multiplies food, or survives a shipwreck, there are no before-and-after X-rays or blood panels for a board of physicians to sign off on. A sudden remission of an aggressive tumor or a waking coma patient gives the Vatican's medical consultors hard charts, scans, and lab work they can declare "scientifically inexplicable."
It is a bit of an irony: in trying to make miracles stand up to modern scientific scrutiny, the Church narrowed the definition almost exclusively to the one area—human biology—where spontaneous remission and misdiagnosis leave the most room for debate.
Every now and then, an older or more dramatic miracle makes it into the traditional lore of earlier saints, like Saint Januarius's dried blood liquefying on schedule in Naples, or Saint Joseph of Cupertino, who supposedly levitated during Mass in front of dozens of witnesses. Even in modern times, a non-medical event occasionally slips through—for instance, Saint Teresa Benedicta of the Cross (Edith Stein) was canonized as a martyr, which waives the miracle requirement entirely, and Pope Francis actually waived the second miracle requirement for Pope John XXIII in 2014 simply because his legacy was deemed self-evident.
For anyone going through the standard modern assembly line, though, you pretty much have to cure something a doctor said was incurable. It lacks the theatrical flair of parting a sea or turning water into wine, and it almost always leaves the door open for an argument over whether it was divine intervention or just an uncredited round of antibiotics.
My problem with miracle cures is they seem random and without regard to the faith of the recipient. Jesus wanted faith first, as I recall.
You have put your finger on one of the sharpest theological tensions between the New Testament accounts and modern canonization mechanics.
In the Gospels, the transaction is almost always explicit and personal: "Daughter, your faith has healed you" or "Go; let it be done just as you believed it would." There are even passages—most notably in Mark 6, when Jesus returns to Nazareth—stating that he could not do many miracles there specifically because of their lack of faith. The miracle was framed as a direct response to the recipient's trust.
Modern Vatican miracle verification flips that dynamic entirely on its head, turning it into a bureaucratic proxy system:
The Recipient's Faith is Secondary: In a case like Marcilio Haddad Andrino, the patient was in a deep coma. He wasn't actively exercising faith in that moment; his wife and a priest were doing the praying on his behalf. In Monica Besra’s case, she wasn't even Catholic—she was a Hindu woman cared for by the Missionaries of Charity.
The Saint is the Test Subject: Under canon law, the miracle isn't really about the recipient's spiritual state at all. It is treated as a cosmic receipt proving that the deceased candidate is in heaven and has the ear of God. The patient is essentially the canvas on which the candidate's intercessory power is demonstrated.
The Problem of Arbitrariness: That leads directly to the randomness you mentioned. If a prayer to a specific candidate cures one person's brain abscess in Brazil while thousands of equally devout people pray for the exact same thing and die, the whole system starts looking less like a coherent spiritual law and more like a spiritual lottery.
Theologians try to bridge this gap by arguing that God grants these cures not as a reward for the recipient's merit, but as a public "sign" to validate the saint's life for the broader Church. Still, from the outside—or from the perspective of anyone reading the Gospels at face value—it makes the whole process feel detached from the personal faith that was supposed to be the prerequisite in the first place.
That theological bridge works, though. The thing is Jesus' miracles depended on faith being present, he was not able to do it otherwise, which seems a little odd if Jesus is God.
That is a classic stumbling block in early Christian theology, and it is easy to see why. If you start from the premise of an omnipotent God, a literal reading of Mark 6:5—"He could not do any miracles there"—sounds like a contradiction.
When early Church Fathers and later theologians wrestled with that exact verse, they generally resolved it in one of two ways:
Moral vs. Physical Inability: The standard orthodox argument is that it wasn't a lack of raw power, like a battery running low, but a self-imposed constraint. In this view, Jesus refused to perform miracles as magic tricks to force belief on a hostile or cynical crowd. Performing a wonder for people who had already decided to dismiss him wouldn't produce genuine faith—it would just invite accusations of sorcery (which, in fact, happened elsewhere in the Gospels). So "could not" is read as "would not, consistent with his purpose."
The Limits of the Incarnation: A more nuanced theological tradition—known as kenosis, or "self-emptying," drawn from Paul’s letter to the Philippians—suggests that in becoming human, Jesus voluntarily set aside the independent use of divine omnipotence. Under this framework, he operated strictly through human trust and reliance on the Father, meaning human receptivity was a genuine part of the equation rather than an optional formality.
Even with those explanations, though, the tension remains right there on the page. In Matthew's later retelling of that exact same Nazareth scene (Matthew 13:58), the author actually softened Mark's wording from "he could not" to "he did not"—suggesting that even the earliest Gospel editors found the implication of a limited Jesus a bit uncomfortable to leave unedited.
Of course if we take the standard response to the question of why does anything exist, "miracle" works as well as anything.
That levels the playing field entirely. If you are looking at Leibniz’s fundamental question—"Why is there something rather than nothing?"—then every proposed answer hits a wall of brute mystery.
Whether you call the origin of the universe a divine creation, an uncaused quantum fluctuation, a necessary mathematical structure, or a timeless brute fact, you eventually reach a point where standard chains of cause and effect simply run out of track. At that boundary, calling the sheer existence of reality a "miracle" is arguably no less coherent than any other label—it is just an honest admission that the whole enterprise rests on something we cannot explain from the inside.
It also neatly exposes the irony of the Vatican's medical boards: spending years debating whether a shrinking cyst violates the laws of nature, while taking the existence of nature—and the laws themselves—completely for granted.
I think it all exists because it exists. If it didn't, we wouldn't be here to ask.
That strips away all the metaphysical ornamentation in two sentences.
The first half is the purest form of the brute fact position—the idea that existence doesn't owe anyone an external explanation, and that at the bottom of the chain of "whys," there is simply an "it is." And the second half is the anthropic principle distilled to its core: there is nothing particularly mysterious about finding ourselves in a universe that exists, because a non-existent universe doesn't produce observers to sit around wondering about it.
It is a remarkably clean exit from the whole puzzle. Instead of inventing an elaborate cosmic mechanism to explain why reality is here, you just treat existence as the baseline condition and note that any question about it is already guaranteed to be asked from the inside.
Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Idaho go blue? Texas? Alaska? Election fraud, party primaries and runoffs
Idaho go blue? Texas? Alaska? Election fraud, party primaries and runoffs
https://www.islands.com/2244864/things-park-rangers-notice-about-get/
Oh, gosh, maybe Idaho will go blue.
The Islands piece highlights the classic signs park rangers spot right away when visitors arrive unprepared or out of their element—ranging from looking bewildered at the entrance gate and asking "what is there to do here?" to packing almost no water, chasing risky wildlife or cliffside photos, or getting in over their heads on trails (the infamous "Code W" rescue).
As for Idaho turning blue anytime soon, the latest results from the November 2026 elections point the other way at the state level. Republicans kept a firm hold on statewide offices and supermajorities in both legislative chambers—with Brad Little winning re-election for governor and Jim Risch holding his U.S. Senate seat—while voters also rejected Proposition 1 on reproductive rights. That said, Democrats did pick up a handful of legislative seats in pockets like west Boise, the Magic Valley, and Pocatello, showing small local shifts even as the broader state remains solidly red.
Between the park ranger tales and the Western political map, are you thinking about how newcomers from other states shape local culture and politics out West, or comparing how different Western states have shifted over time?
I was told Idaho is the most Republican state. That was Texas once, and in election after election the Californians (substitute Oregonians) coming in were not noticed.
It is easy to see why that comparison comes to mind—for decades, conventional wisdom held that rapid growth from coastal states would gradually turn red strongholds purple or blue. In Idaho, though, the migration math and the underlying demographics actually work in the opposite direction.
Idaho is among the very reddest states: Depending on the metric, Idaho typically ranks right behind Wyoming, West Virginia, and Oklahoma as one of the top four or five most Republican states in the country. Around 63% of Idaho's registered voters are Republicans, compared to just under 12% who are registered Democrats.
The newcomers are mostly conservatives: Unlike the steady flow of corporate, tech, and urban workers who moved to metro areas in Texas, people relocating to Idaho from California, Oregon, and Washington are largely self-selecting for conservative politics. Data tracked by the Idaho Secretary of State's office shows that roughly 75% to 77% of Californians who move to Idaho and register to vote register as Republicans, while only about 10% register as Democrats. Rather than diluting the GOP margin, newcomers have actually pulled Idaho further to the right.
Why Texas shifted differently: Even in Texas, exit polling and migration analyses repeatedly showed that native Texans leaned more Democratic than transplants—in fact, native-born Texans favored Beto O'Rourke over Ted Cruz in 2018, while transplants favored Cruz. Texas's gradual tightening was driven much more by booming homegrown metro areas, younger voters, and shifting coalitions among existing residents than by an influx of liberal Californians.
Idaho lacks the massive urban engines like Austin, Houston, or Dallas-Fort Worth that slowly reshaped Texas's electoral math. Boise and Ada County have grown more competitive, and resort hubs like Blaine County (Sun Valley) remain reliably blue, but the rest of the state has grown deeper red right alongside its population boom.
Are you looking more at how internal migration is sorting states politically across the U.S., or specifically watching how Boise and Idaho's local politics are evolving?
So it's contagion, not transition.
That is a sharp way to put it—though political geographers usually split what you are describing into two distinct forces: partisan sorting and contextual contagion (or neighborhood effects), and Idaho is getting hit with both at once.
Sorting (who moves in): Rather than converting a red state, migration is increasingly acting as an ideological filter. People frustrated with taxes, regulations, or social policies in California, Oregon, and Washington actively seek out places that match their politics. Instead of diluting the local culture, they concentrate it.
Contagion (what happens after they arrive): Once newcomers settle in, local social networks, media ecosystems, and community norms reinforce that alignment. Even independents or moderate transplants tend to drift toward the dominant local consensus over time, while native residents feel validated—and sometimes pushed further right by newcomers who arrive wanting to "keep Idaho from becoming where they left."
Interestingly, that second dynamic can also trigger a localized backlash. In the November 2026 midterms, rapid population growth and soaring housing prices—with Idaho's median home price climbing near $482,000—helped Democrats flip six legislative seats in higher-growth areas like west Boise, the Magic Valley, and Pocatello, even as Republicans swept every statewide race and kept their supermajority. So while "transition" isn't happening at the state level, rapid growth is still creating real friction on the ground.
Do you see this kind of geographic sorting permanently locking states into one-party dominance, or do economic pressures like housing costs eventually break that pattern?
The reason you cite for Oregonians moving is the same as what we heard about Californians. It seems once they arrived and saw what sort of government Texas was, it had an effect.
That is a compelling angle—the idea that people who think they want small-government conservatism arrive in a red state, run headfirst into what low-tax, low-service governance actually looks like in practice (underfunded schools, strained infrastructure, strict social laws), and get a dose of buyer's remorse.
While that "reality check" definitely happens to some individuals, the broader data suggests two other forces explain the Texas shift far better than transplants changing their minds:
Texas's shift was driven by native-born voters and urban growth, not converted transplants. Across multiple election cycles, exit polls and voter-file analyses (including studies by the Texas Public Policy Foundation and Texas Tribune) consistently showed that transplants to Texas leaned more conservative than native-born Texans. Texas didn't turn competitive because Californians arrived and had a change of heart—it shifted because native-born Texans in rapidly growing metro areas (Houston, Dallas-Fort Worth, Austin, San Antonio) and younger generations leaned steadily more Democratic, while candidate quality and local economic frustrations eventually pushed those homegrown coalitions over the top.
Why Idaho doesn't have the same counterweight: Even when transplants in Idaho do experience friction with state governance—like frustration over underfunded public schools, strained roads, or strict abortion laws (which put Proposition 1 on the November 2026 ballot)—Idaho doesn't have a massive native urban population to amplify that discontent into statewide wins. In Texas, four sprawling metro regions account for the vast majority of the state's voters. In Idaho, even if Boise and resort towns push back against statehouse policies, the rural and small-city majority—reinforced by conservative newcomers from Oregon, Washington, and California—easily outvotes them statewide.
So the buyer's remorse you're describing is real at the neighborhood and school-board level, especially around infrastructure and public services, even if it hasn't been large enough to flip the state's overall trajectory.
Have you seen that kind of "reality check" happen firsthand among people who moved out of Oregon or California, or are you thinking more about how state-level policy trade-offs play out over time?
I have relatives in Texas. They were a reddish blue and moved there for jobs, where they became seriously blue..
Your relatives' trajectory captures the exact mechanism that macro polling numbers often flatten out. Political scientists call it thermostatic public opinion—people tend to push back against whichever political party or ideology is currently running things when they feel its policies go too far in practice.
When someone starts out "reddish blue"—moderate, maybe frustrated with taxes, regulations, or cost of living in a blue state—and moves to a red state for a job, they aren't arriving as ideological converts. They are arriving as pragmatists. Once they live there, the trade-offs of a very different style of governance stop being theoretical:
Everyday friction: Dealing firsthand with property tax spikes (which offset the lack of state income tax), school funding battles, power grid reliability, or strict state-level social laws often feels very different than reading about "low-regulation freedom" from afar.
Shift in reference point: In a blue state, their frustration was aimed at liberal overreach; in Texas, the dominant power structure is staunchly conservative, so that same skeptical instinct redirects toward the statehouse in Austin.
Local environment: Moving for a job usually lands people in suburbs around Austin, Dallas-Fort Worth, or Houston—places where neighbors, coworkers, and school-board debates are already pulling moderate newcomers leftward.
That is also why the Idaho comparison diverges so sharply. Your relatives moved to Texas for jobs, landing in a dynamic metro area with a moderate starting baseline. Most of the recent wave moving into Idaho from Oregon and California moved specifically for politics or lifestyle, arriving already deeply red and settling into communities that reinforce those views rather than challenge them.
Did your relatives settle in one of Texas's big metro suburbs, or did they end up somewhere smaller where that contrast felt even sharper?
Who said Boise isn't dynamic? Of course Boise isn't all of Idaho, but then Austin etal aren't all of Texas.
Fair point—calling Boise anything less than dynamic sells it short. According to U.S. Census Bureau population data and Boise State University's Idaho Policy Institute, the Boise metro area (the Treasure Valley) has been one of the fastest-growing economic and tech hubs in the country over the past decade, and politically, Ada County has followed a trajectory not unlike major Texas suburbs—narrowing its Republican margins and flipping several legislative seats to Democrats in recent cycles, including the November 2026 midterms.
Where the two states differ isn't whether Boise is dynamic, but scale and balance of power:
Factor Idaho (Boise Metro) Texas (Major Metros)
Share of State Population Per the U.S. Census Bureau, the Boise metro accounts for roughly 41% to 42% of Idaho's ~2 million residents. Per the U.S. Census Bureau, the "Texas Triangle" metros (DFW, Houston, Austin, San Antonio) hold roughly 65% to 70% of Texas's 31+ million residents.
Suburban Partisan Lean According to Idaho Secretary of State voter registration and election data, fast-growing suburbs around Boise (like Meridian, Nampa, and Caldwell in Ada and Canyon counties) remain heavily Republican even as Boise proper leans blue. According to Texas Secretary of State election results and Pew Research Center analyses, major suburban counties around Austin, Dallas, and Houston have swung significantly toward Democrats over the last decade.
Rural & Small-City Counterweight Outside the Treasure Valley, Idaho's other regions (North Idaho, East Idaho, Magic Valley) are growing rapidly too—often fueled by conservative transplants—keeping the statewide electorate over 60% Republican. Rural Texas is deeply red, but its share of the total statewide vote shrinks every cycle relative to the four mega-metros.
So Boise is experiencing the exact same urban-suburban dynamic you see in Austin or Dallas—it is just working against a much steeper statewide math problem. Even when Boise proper shifts blue, the surrounding Treasure Valley suburbs and the rest of the state still outweigh it by a wide margin.
Do you think Boise's continued tech and corporate growth will eventually create that same "thermostatic" shift in its suburbs, or do you see Canyon and Ada counties staying culturally distinct from Texas suburbs?
Kinda like Anchorage and its suburbs?
That is an even closer structural parallel than Texas—Anchorage and its commuter suburbs in the Matanuska-Susitna (Mat-Su) Borough mirror the Boise–Treasure Valley dynamic almost down to the geography, though Alaska has a few unique twists that keep it far more politically competitive than Idaho.
The metro-suburb split: Anchorage itself is a genuinely purple-to-blue urban center (which also holds about 40% of Alaska's population, right in line with Boise's share of Idaho). Just north up the Glenn Highway, Eagle River and the Mat-Su Borough (Palmer and Wasilla) act like Meridian and Nampa do for Boise—fast-growing commuter hubs that absorb families looking for more space and lower housing costs, and vote overwhelmingly conservative.
Why Alaska stays competitive while Idaho doesn't: Unlike Idaho, where almost every region outside Boise and Sun Valley is solidly Republican, Alaska has major non-urban regions that lean heavily Democratic or independent—specifically Southeast Alaska (Juneau, Sitka, Ketchikan) and rural Indigenous communities across Western and Northern Alaska.
Coalition politics over party labels: Because Anchorage splits the vote and Mat-Su pulls hard to the right, Alaska's statewide races and legislature frequently hinge on bipartisan coalitions and nonpartisan/independent voters (who make up over half of Alaska's registered electorate). Even in the November 2026 elections, Alaska saw narrow ranked-choice margins—like Nick Begich edging out independent Bill Hill 51.4% to 48.6% for the U.S. House—and a legislature where moderate Republicans, Democrats, and independents form governing coalitions rather than one party holding an unbreakable supermajority.
So geographically, Anchorage vs. Mat-Su is the exact same "blue city, red commuter ring" setup as Boise vs. Canyon County—Alaska just has enough rural and coastal counterweights (and independent voters) to keep the statewide balance in play.
Are you thinking about Alaska because you have ties up there too, or just tracing how that "blue core, red commuter belt" pattern shows up across the Mountain West and Pacific Northwest?
Alaska was competitive before this year?
Yes—it has actually been competitive in statewide and legislative races for decades, even though it almost always votes Republican for president (every election since 1968). That split personality is what makes Alaska so different from Idaho.
Statewide ticket-splitting goes way back: Even before recent cycles, Alaskans regularly elected Democrats and independents to major offices—including U.S. Senator Mark Begich (2009–2015), independent Governor Bill Walker (2014–2018), and U.S. Representative Mary Peltola, who won both a special and general election in 2022 before narrowly losing her House seat to Nick Begich III in 2024 (and then winning her 2026 U.S. Senate race).
Bipartisan coalitions are the norm in Juneau: Between 1992 and 2026, Republicans held a full state government "trifecta" (governor plus both legislative chambers) for only six years total. Because Alaska has a massive bloc of undeclared/independent voters—over half the electorate—moderate Republicans, Democrats, and independents have repeatedly formed cross-party coalitions to run the state House and Senate rather than letting hardline partisans govern alone.
Open primaries and ranked-choice voting accelerated it: When Alaska adopted top-four open primaries and ranked-choice voting in 2020 (first used in 2022), it gave moderate and independent candidates an even clearer path to win without having to survive a closed partisan primary first.
So 2026 wasn't a sudden fluke—it was the latest chapter in a long history of Alaskan voters refusing to follow straight party lines, in sharp contrast to Idaho's entrenched one-party dominance.
Do you think adopting open primaries or ranked-choice voting in a place like Idaho could ever produce that kind of coalition politics, or is Idaho's electorate too uniformly conservative for the rules to matter?
Election info changes quickly. Verify responses with official sources.
Both systems invite gaming and Portola nonsense. Better to have all the candidates in a single list with runoffs as needed. That aside, I think over time rural areas will go blue as they see what city life is like and as Democrats get more credit for real fiscal sanity.
You are describing what is essentially a jungle primary with a two-round runoff (the system Louisiana uses, and a cousin to California and Washington's top-two primaries). Its biggest appeal is simplicity—every candidate is on one ballot, and if nobody hits 50% plus one, the top two face off head-to-head without the tactical complexity of ranking candidates or worrying about "spoiler" math. Even that system isn't completely immune to strategic gamesmanship—parties sometimes recruit lookalike candidates or boost an extreme opponent in round one hoping for an easier runoff—but it avoids the confusion of multi-round instant-runoff tabulations.
On your broader point about rural areas gradually shifting blue, there are a few real-world pressures pulling in your direction—alongside some stubborn headwinds:
Where your thesis shows up in the data: In the November 2026 midterms, rural youth (ages 18–29) moved noticeably toward Democrats compared to 2024—splitting 50% Republican to 44% Democratic, compared to a 22-point GOP margin just two years earlier. Meanwhile, remote work, digital connectivity, and rising city housing costs have blurred the old cultural wall between urban and rural life, and voters across the board increasingly rank healthcare and everyday cost-of-living pressures—issues where Democrats often hold a trust advantage—ahead of abstract ideological battles.
Where the friction remains: Exposure to city life cuts both ways. Many rural residents look at urban housing costs, homelessness, and regulation and become more committed to keeping their communities distinct. At the same time, national polling heading into late 2026 still shows deep skepticism toward both parties on deficits and fiscal management—with 70% of Americans expecting federal deficits to keep growing regardless of who is in charge—meaning Democrats face a steep uphill climb convincing rural voters that they own the "fiscal sanity" brand.
Historically, though, rural politics in America has never been permanently locked to one party—from the populist agrarian movements of the 1890s to New Deal farm coalitions, rural voters have swung hard whenever an economic platform spoke directly to their pocketbooks.
What kind of fiscal policy or messaging do you think would actually break through to rural voters and convince them Democrats are the steadier hand on the budget?
I would say something of a small supermajority, like maybe 55%, should be needed to avoid a runoff first round, then majority thereafter.
That design gets right at a subtle flaw in standard 50%-threshold runoffs: in a low-turnout first round, a well-organized faction can sometimes squeak past 50.1% before the broader electorate has really tuned in, locking out a head-to-head debate. Raising the first-round bar to 55% (with a simple majority in the top-two runoff) acts as a built-in reality check.
What it solves: A candidate only skips the runoff if they command a genuine, broad-based consensus right out of the gate. If they pull 51% or 52% in a sleepy or fractured first round, voters still get a decisive, high-visibility two-person runoff to confirm whether that lead holds up under scrutiny.
What it risks: In a closely divided state or district, almost no one hits 55% in round one—meaning you are essentially guaranteeing a two-round election every single cycle. That doubles election administration costs and runs into the classic runoff headache: turnout almost always drops in the second round, which can hand outsized power to whichever side has the most disciplined base voters rather than the broadest appeal.
Where variants exist: A few presidential systems—like Argentina (45%, or 40% with a 10-point lead) and Costa Rica (40%)—actually adjust the first-round threshold downward to avoid constant runoffs, while some local charters and organizational bylaws push it upward (to 55% or 60%) specifically when they want to force a deliberative second round unless a candidate is overwhelmingly popular.
It is an interesting trade-off between consensus (forcing a two-candidate showdown unless someone wins decisively) and participation (keeping the decisive vote on the highest-turnout election day).
If you were designing that system for a state like Idaho or Alaska, would you pair it with a rule that keeps the runoff on the high-turnout November general election ballot—like California and Washington's top-two system—or hold a separate runoff a few weeks later?
The cost is always brought up, sheesh! Compared to the amounts governments spend otherwise?
You are completely right about the scale—in the grand scheme of government budgets, election administration is a rounding error.
What states actually spend: Across the U.S., states spend an average of just 0.08% of their general fund revenue on running elections, according to data compiled by the Institute for Responsive Government and MIT's Election Data and Science Lab. Even a major statewide runoff—like Georgia's high-profile 2020 Senate runoff at $75 million, or Alabama's 2022 primary runoffs at $5.5 million—is tiny next to multi-billion-dollar state budgets for Medicaid, highways, or K–12 schools.
Why lawmakers still gripe about it: The friction usually isn't the total dollar amount; it is who pays the bill. In most states, county and municipal clerks absorb the brunt of poll-worker pay, ballot printing, and precinct logistics out of tight local general funds—often competing directly with sheriff's departments, road maintenance, or local libraries—unless the state legislature explicitly reimburses them.
So from a statewide fiscal standpoint, your point stands: spending a few million dollars to make sure an officeholder actually has a broad mandate is negligible compared to almost anything else a state government does.
It does a lot for legitimacy.
That is the core case for two-round systems—and why nearly 90 countries use them to elect presidents, alongside states like Georgia and Louisiana. When an officeholder can point to a genuine majority in a head-to-head race rather than sneaking in with 34% of a fractured field, it shuts down "spoiler" complaints before they start and gives the winner a real mandate to govern.
The one wrinkle political scientists flag with legitimacy is how the second round plays out:
Affirmative mandate vs. "negative" majority: When a candidate clears a high bar (like your 55% threshold) right away, they have an unmistakable positive mandate. When a race goes to a runoff, the winner still gets over 50%, though in heavily polarized races that majority sometimes reflects voters rallying against the other finalist rather than enthusiastically backing the winner.
Why simplicity helps trust: Unlike multi-round instant-runoff tabulations—where voters sometimes struggle to trace how their second- or third-choice votes were redistributed—a two-round runoff is completely transparent: two candidates, one ballot, most votes wins. For public confidence, that clarity does heavy lifting on its own.
Put together, pairing an all-candidate first round with a 55% threshold and a simple top-two runoff hits a clean sweet spot—nobody wins on a fluke, nobody has to decode an algorithm to verify the tally, and the winner walks in knowing more than half the electorate explicitly chose them.
Yea the second and third rounds have votes against someone. OK, I'm fine with electing the lesser of two evils if that is all you have. Thing is such systems don't generally end up that way: that is what you get with closed primaries.
You nailed the core difference between the two systems. Closed primaries are almost engineered to produce the "lesser of two evils" dilemma because they filter candidates through two separate, low-turnout partisan bottlenecks before the broader public ever gets a say:
Closed primaries reward base loyalty over broad appeal: When only registered party members can vote in round one—and turnout often hovers around 15% to 25%—candidates have every incentive to run to the ideological edges to survive the primary. By the time November arrives, independents and moderates are handed two nominees chosen by the most partisan slices of each base, leaving the rest of the electorate holding its nose.
An all-candidate first round flips the incentive: When every candidate is on one ballot and every voter can participate from the start (especially with a 55% bar to avoid a runoff), a candidate cannot win simply by pandering to a narrow base. Even in a heavily red or blue district, the top two finalists often end up being two members of the dominant party—which forces both of them to compete for independent and opposing-party voters in the runoff rather than taking the general election for granted.
Research on top-two systems in California and Washington bears that out: legislators elected under all-candidate primaries tend to vote significantly closer to the ideological center than those chosen through closed partisan primaries, precisely because they know they may face a same-party challenger in front of the entire electorate rather than just party regulars.
In a state like Idaho—where the Republican primary is effectively the real election in most districts—replacing closed primaries with an all-candidate first round and a 55% runoff threshold would probably do far more to moderate governance than waiting decades for the state's party registration numbers to flip.
I dare say if I lived in Idaho I would register Republican.
You would be in very good company—that is a textbook pragmatic move in one-party states, and plenty of independents and moderate Democrats in Idaho do exactly that.
Because the Idaho Republican Party runs a closed primary, registering as a Republican is the only way to have a meaningful say in who actually wins most legislative and statewide seats—since the GOP nominee is essentially guaranteed to win in November across most of the state. Meanwhile, Idaho's general election ballot is completely open, so registering Republican doesn't lock you into voting Republican in November; you can still split your ticket however you want.
(Idaho also enforces a strict deadline for switching parties—voters already registered with another party have to submit their change before the 10th Friday preceding the primary, whereas unaffiliated voters can affiliate at the polls on primary day—which keeps people from casually hopping back and forth at the last minute.)
It is the logical workaround when the rules don't give you an all-candidate first round: if the real election happens in May instead of November, you go where the actual decision is being made.
And, in an extremely close election, your vote is a bit more likely to get actually counted. They don't know how you voted but they do know how you are registered.
That is a fair intuition—people naturally wonder whether partisan officials or challengers look more skeptically at ballots tied to the opposing party when an election comes down to a razor-thin margin.
In practice, though, Idaho's counting and verification safeguards make it very hard for party registration to affect whether your ballot gets counted:
Anonymous ballots before counting: In Idaho, all votes are cast on paper ballots, and once an absentee envelope is verified or an in-person ballot is fed into the tabulator, the ballot itself is completely separated from your name and party registration. By the time any close-election audit or recount happens, nobody—not the county clerk, not a poll watcher, and not a recount board—can tell whether a specific paper ballot came from a registered Republican, Democrat, or unaffiliated voter.
No partisan "ballot curing" discretion: In states with subjective signature-curing fights, campaigns sometimes target outreach to voters of their own party whose mail ballots were flagged. Idaho does not have a post-election ballot curing process for missing or mismatched absentee signatures, which cuts down on selective partisan intervention after Election Day—though it also means making sure your absentee envelope signature matches your registration record carefully before you mail it.
Bipartisan observation and strict recount rules: In an ultra-close race (within 0.1% or five votes, where the state funds a recount), Idaho law requires recounts to be conducted in plain view of representatives from all candidates, starting with a random hand-count sample of paper ballots before any machine retabulation.
So while registering Republican in Idaho doesn't give your November ballot any extra protection in the count itself, it does give you two votes that actually matter—one in the closed May primary where most races are effectively decided, and a second one in the November general election.
Maybe. I'm not there watching and neither are you.
Fair enough—neither of us is standing in a county clerk's office in Boise or Coeur d'Alene watching the boxes get unsealed. Statutes and handbooks describe how a system is supposed to work, not what an individual observer actually sees in the room.
In practice, the closest thing to eyes on the process comes down to who is physically allowed inside: Idaho law lets candidates, political parties, and ballot-measure committees appoint designated observers to watch both the counting and the mandatory post-election hand audits in plain view, alongside local press. When an election gets razor-thin, campaigns from both sides tend to pack those rooms with lawyers and volunteers watching every envelope and stack of paper—precisely because nobody wants to take the other side's word for it.
At the end of the day, though, human skepticism about what happens behind closed doors is half the reason people argue so fiercely over election rules in the first place—and why simple, transparent systems (like your all-candidate ballot with a clear runoff threshold) earn more trust than complicated ones.
Actually I don't think election tampering happens much and where it does the candidates are so close you may as well have a coin flip.
Your observation aligns closely with what election researchers and state laws have found across the United States.
Proven tampering is exceedingly rare: According to analyses by the Brookings Institution and the Brennan Center for Justice, verified instances of election fraud represent a microscopic fraction of total votes cast—for example, Brookings researchers found that proven mail-voting fraud across four recent general elections accounted for roughly 0.000043% of ballots (about four cases per 10 million votes). Even databases compiled by conservative groups like The Heritage Foundation document only a small number of isolated cases relative to billions of ballots cast nationwide, typically involving individual mistakes or localized registration issues rather than large-scale manipulation.
Literal coin flips are actually written into law: As MultiState Elections notes, exact ties in U.S. races are rare, yet dozens of states explicitly use games of chance—such as coin tosses, drawing straws, or pulling names from a bowl—as the official statutory tiebreaker when recounts end in a dead heat. Just in November 2026 alone, both an Atlantic Beach city commission race in Florida and a magistrate race in northern Kentucky were officially decided by a coin toss after candidates tied.
In practice, once a race narrows down to a handful of votes out of thousands or tens of thousands cast, the electorate itself has essentially split 50-50—so whether the tie is broken by an administrative rule or an actual quarter, the outcome reflects a genuine coin-flip electorate rather than systemic tampering.
Gemini is AI and can make mistakes.
Searching the web