What we appear to lose when our brains are damaged seems to have to do
mainly with memory -- retrieving and storing them. The personality
seems to remain but of course cannot function well without the ability
to remember things, or confusion and partial memories. Eventually, when
even short-term memory is lost,. even the personality seems to go, but
it is hard to really make that assertion, and even then the elements of
sentient existence -- experience of "qualia" -- the ability, for instance,
to discern faces and colors and other sensations, to feel pain and
hunger, and all the rest -- seems to remain.
This fits but of course does not imply the South Central Asian (Indian
subcontinent) cultural idea of rebirth -- at death memories are lost but
the personality goes on, not as a tangible thing but as a process. The
cultures of this area had no problem assigning sentience to animals,
but not souls, which to the cultures involved was alien (the ideas are
sometimes translated "souls," or "self," but this is a distortion.
No comments:
Post a Comment