The Ten Commandments

It's informative sometimes to ask a person who insists they follow or are guided by God's Law what law in particular they mean.

Of course one often gets "the Bible." Well obviously the Bible has some laws in it, but it is not a law book.  Besides, Christians, at least, do not follow most of the Bible laws, found in the Mosaic Law.  Various explanations are given for this,  having to do with that Law having been "fulfilled," or replaced by the Law of Love.

I have no idea how anything Jesus did could have fulfilled the law, and as I recall he went out of his way to be explicit that nothing in that law was to be ignored or broken -- just that common sense was needed in its application (the Sabbath can be broken in emergencies is, as I recall, the example he gave).

When asked to see some specific laws found in the Bible, we of course almost always get the Ten Commandments.  One has to ask, since the Mosaic Law is fulfilled and since the Ten Commandments are obviously part of this, why just it, and not all of the Mosaic Law, is considered valid.

The Ten Commandments are of course on the whole an excellent guide, so long as not taken too literally (the common sense rule) and not taken as anything near a complete ethics guide (for example it does not prohibit slavery or discrimination or using legal process to force others to observe one's personal ethics).  It is also composed of "shalt not" commands, and there are some affirmative things that should be in one's basic ethical beliefs -- such as giving to charities, doing safe and healthy things, etc.

The Commandment having to do with the Sabbath is of course specific to the tradition, but there is no problem I see with mandating a day of rest.  That it has to be one day in seven as a minimum is a bit silly, and this probably should not be part of a basic law as it does not rise to the level of honesty and fidelity in marriage, let alone not killing people.

The Sabbath law has also had the perverse effect of forcing a seven day week on our calendar, which has made it resistant to decimalization and unnecessarily complicated the calendar.  A ten day week with two or three Sabbaths would in my mind be better.  Going to church on a Sabbath is also inconsistent -- it is supposed to be a day of rest.

The main problem is with the statement that Jehovah (YHVH) is said to be a "jealous" God.  That is an obvious hold-over from the days when monotheism was not established and the actual existence of other gods was still believed -- otherwise what does Jehovah have to be jealous of?  The real problem here though is not its illogicality but its implication of intolerance.

God's jealousy also leads to to the ban on idolatry.  It goes so far as to ban the making of images entirely -- something Islam has taken beyond common sense and is of course impossible in the modern world (photo id's for example).  The fact is that there is no such thing as idolatry -- no one thinks the statue is actually the god -- this is brought out in the defense of Christian icons -- they are aids for focus and art works incorporating religious feelings.  When the Buddhist bows to the Buddha, no one thinks the Buddha is actually present in the statue -- it is respect and tradition and things like that, not "worship." (One day I must do a blog on the meaninlessness of the concept of worship anyway).  Ask any Buddhist -- the Buddha is dead.

If I were to scan the Bible for ethics, I would probably concentrate on the Sermon on the Mount -- something to be read from time to time for its lack of hypocrisy, its common sense, and its affirmative commands (along with things not to do).  I will maybe deal with this another day.