Any truly eternal ethical laws would be independent of God. What is
right is right and what is wrong is wrong, and this applies to any
divinities as well as to people.
This of course assumes that right and wrong exist as objective, real
"things." One is tempted to say they are analogous to ideas of beauty
and ugliness, entirely in the eye of the beholder. But beauty is not
entirely in the eye of the beholder (while superficially this is so we
have to recognize that beauty does have a deeper quality that outlasts
cultures and fashions).
A better analogy might be right and wrong are analogous to truth and
falsehood. Even though people have varying ideas of what is true and
what is not, we tend in the end to agree that truth and falsehood exist
on their own independent of our opinions.
Don't confuse human ideas of right and wrong with real right and
wrong. Human ideas change and indeed seem to progress (slavery is not
condemned as wrong), but in the end mankind has always known slavery was
wrong, and just buried its head. At least those who stopped to think
objectively about it reached that conclusion.
No comments:
Post a Comment